Powered by Textbook Widget

Search here for medical pg entrance books you want to buy

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

SC reserves order on pleas against NEET


SC reserves order on pleas against NEET


The Supreme Court on Tuesday reserved its order on a bunch of petitions, including one from pre-university students from Karnataka, challenging the MCI’s decision to conduct National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) for admissions to MBBS and BDS courses.

A three-judge bench presided over by Chief Justice Altamas Kabir concluded the hearing in the matter but gave different parties including, the Centre and Medical Council of India (MCI) to file their written submission, if any, within two days.

The students, pursuing their PUC-II year, represented by advocate G S Kannur contended that they had not studied the syllabus prescribed by the CBSE which was 30 to 35 per cent more than the one recommended at their state board.

A group of unaided medical colleges as well as religious and linguistic minority institutions, along with Christian Medical College, Vellore, wanted permission to conduct their own examination on the ground that the decision to impose NEET would tamper with their independence character.

The Centre as well as the MCI, on the other hand, contended that there have been a lot of allegations of corruption and irregularities in the examinations conducted by colleges and state boards. A uniform system of examination would not only be fair and transparent but would also save students from hassles of running from here and there to appear in different examinations, they said.

The NEET is scheduled for May 5 across the country except Karnataka where it is going to be held on May 18 due to state assembly elections. In their writ petition, the Karnataka students had urged the court to quash the notification issued by the MCI on February 15 last year and restrain the CBSE from conducting the NEET for admission to first year MBBS for the academic year 2013-2014 in Karnataka as it is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

NEET CASE UPDATES 30.04.2013


NEET CASE TC(C)98/2012 LAST HEARING WAS ON APRIL 25TH.SO MUCH CONFUSION PREVAIL AFTER APRIL 25TH WHETHER NEXT DATE IS FOR VERDICT OR HEARING ..NOW COURT WEBSITE UPDATED CASE STATUS.NEXT HEARING ON 30TH.FINAL CAUSE LIST FOR 30TH APRIL NOT PUBLISHED YET.WE CAN EXPECT THIS WILL BE FINAL HEARING..

FINAL CAUSE LIST FOR NEXT TUESDAY(30.04.2013) PUBLISHED NEET CASE INCLUDED AS ITEM NO 1   .CASE IS FOR HEARING NOT FOR ORDERS .INCLUDING 30TH APRIL ONLY 3 POSSIBLE HEARING DAYS REMAIN BEFORE SUMMER HOLIDAYS.MOSTLY CASE WONT DELAY BEYOND SUMMER HOLIDAYS.
ITEM NUMBER 1 IN COURT 1.BENCH WILL SIT UP TO 2.55pm.WHOLE DAY OF HEARING AGAIN ON 30TH APRIL.CAN EXPECT CASE WILL END ON 30TH.
.MOSTLY CASE WILL GET OVER THEN..
10.45 am.COURT 1 NOT IN SESSION.COURT 1 WILL BE IN SESSION BY 11 AM.OTHER COURTS ARE NOW IN SESSION
11 am COURT 1 STARTED WITH ITEM NO 31.STARTED WITH SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSE LIST IT SEEMS
11.05 am NEET CASE STARTED.WE EXPECT THIS WILL BE LAST HEARING AND DATE FOR VERDICT MAY BE GIVEN TODAY..WE WILL UPDATE YOU THE INFORMATION ABOUT NEET CASE
TODAY COURT WILL BE IN SESSION TILL 2.55PM.SPECIAL COURT STARTING AT 3PM.LAWYERS THAT ARGUMENTS REMAIN ARE OF UOI,CBSE ,AND NATIONAL BOARD..THAT WILL MOSTLY GET OVER BY TODAY..A DATE FOR VERDICT MOSTLY BE ANNOUNCED TODAY..HAVE A CLOSE WATCH ON TODAY'S HEARING
11.55pm NEET CASE CONTINUES IN COURT 1..LUNCH BREAK IS USUALLY FROM 1 TO 2PM ..AS THERE IS NO CASE GIVEN SPECIFIC TIME IN CAUSE LIST.. NEET CASE WILL CONTINUE IN AFTERNOON SESSION ALSO 
12.35 pm HALF AN HOUR TO GO BEFORE LUNCH BREAK..STILL NEET CASE CONTINUES IN COURT 1.
12.45 PM ITEM NO 931 NOW IN COURT 1..YET TO SEE NEET CASE ENDED OR NOT WE WILL INFORM YOU DETAILS SOON
NEET CASE JUST GOT OVER FEW MINUTES BEFORE .WILL INFORM YOU DETAILS SOON
HOT NEWS
NEET CASE OVER..ALL LAWYERS WILL SUBMIT WRITTEN SUBMISSION..WILL INFORM YOU MORE DETAILS SOON..WRITTEN SUBMISSION WILL BE MADE BY ALL LAWYERS BY THURSDAY..VERDICT DATE WILL BE GIVEN LATER..


DOWNLOADS

DNB

Guidelines for candidates who have deposited their Original documents/certificates in the Medical College/Institute

DNB SECOND ROUND COUNSELLING FROM JULY 15TH

Family physicians are dying a silent death

Why DNB exam tougher than MS/MD exam?

CHECK ALL THIS BEFORE DNB COUNSELLING

.GOOD HOSPITALS FOR DOING DNB

.NUMBER OF SEATS IN VARIOUS SPECIALITY IN DNB JAN 2013

.WHICH SEAT YOU WILL GET IN DNB? PART 1


INFORMATION ABOUT COUNSELLING

NEW NOTICES IN MCC

IMPORTANT NOTICE-4TH ROUND COUNSELLING 2013

3RD ROUND ALL INDIA COUNSELLING

WHICH SEAT YOU WILL GET WITH YOUR RANK

These are answers to your doubts regarding online all india counselling
BOND AND STIPEND INFORMATION IN STATES IN ALL INDIA COUNSELLING 
INITIAL VACANCY POSITION IN LAST YEAR ALL INDIA COUNSELLING


CASE STATUS

NEET FINAL VERDICT UPDATE

Final cause list for 10th may and supplementary cause list for 8th published
COUNT DOWN 4 DAYS LEFT BEFORE HOLIDAYS

Thousands waiting ,When can NEET results expected?

Supreme court website updated case status

NEWS REPORTS

Medical College managements bypass ASC directive

Government's decision on doubling medical PG seats might be impractical

Doctors protest against rural posting

Why medical students are fighting rural posting

.Junior doctors to go on strike from July 22

 .Minister to hold meeting of VCs to iron out issues

.NEET-PG 2013: Private colleges not considering NEET results

.PG medical seats on sale for Rs 1 crore!-TOI REPORT

.NEET PG results out, counselling to follow

.Doctors need urgent ‘medical’ attention

.Students zapped: 4 colleges, same counselling date

.Uncertainty over PG medical counselling procedure

."We will come out with the results shortly," said NBE spokesperson, Dr V Gupta

.Duplication of an admission process and needless waste of time, money and effort

.COUNSELLING SCHEDULES WILL CLASH

.“There is no clarity in the court’s order on the time frame or extension of deadline for the counselling ".Dr IV Reddy.


.Apex order on NEET cramps PGET schedule

."students who aspire to gain entry into medical colleges at the MBBS, BDS and the post-graduate level have been caught in a legal tangle for no fault of theirs and are the victims of policy decisions".


.VERDICT ON NEET WONT AFFECT KERALA STATE


.RESPONSE BY PG ASPIRANTS ABOUT NEET AT THIS MOMENT

.REPORTS ABOUT NEET VERDICT IN TODAY'S NEWSPAPERS'
.REPORTS ON NEET VERDICT
.NEET judgment likely on Monday-DECCAN CHRONICLE

.PG ADMISSIONS HIT :The NEET controversy had affected even the Medical PG admissions.

.NEET, not yet

."everything" would be done to ensure that students are not affected in any manner. "That's all I can say right now",Dr KK Talwar said.
.Today's report in HINDU on verdict
.FAKE NEWS SPREADING IN NEWS PAPERS :NEET-PG 2013: Final case verdict today
.Private medical colleges in the state have threatened not to undertake fresh admissions unless fee is hiked for the block period 2013-2016
.Thousands waiting ,When can NEET results expected?
.Report in daily bhaskar:NEET-PG 2013: Verdict on results expected on May 9

.MCI said the NEET would avoid multiple entrance tests and minimise corruption and irregularities in admissions-THE HINDU


NEET CASE SUMMARY

When we stand here at the end of all hearings and waiting for verdict we can just look back what all had happened in NEET case.
NEET exam was declared by MCI in September that too with instruction of court for a fair and transparent system in medical  dental and pg admissions.Exam was conducted by National board of examinations on November 23rd to December 6.Around 90000 doctors wrote NEET PG entrance
Private medical colleges and many state governments move to honorable supreme court against NEET and for conducting their on exams.
There were more than 20 petitioners and case started on November 5.Honorable Supreme court given an interim order on December 13 for all institutions and state governments to conduct their own exams and instructed not to publish results of any medical/pg entrance till further order
This is the order that come in NBE as well as MCI site


O R D E R 
In all these matters, which are before us, the main question 
which has been urged is with regard to the applicability of the 
decision by the Medical Council of India to conduct National Eligibility 
and Entrance Test for both M.B.B.S. and Post-Graduate Courses for 
Medicine. In addition to the above, there is also the question of 
admission into B.D.S. and M.D.S. Examinations. 
Having heard learned counsel representing different parties, while 
we are of the view that the main matters which are pending need to 
be heard and decided at an early stage, the time taken in hearing the 
matters should be utilised in allowing the students to sit for their 
respective examinations, which are already notified. Accordingly, 
let all the transferred cases, as well as the writ petitions, be listed for 
final hearing and disposal, irrespective of other part-heard or 
specially fixed matters on 15th, 16th and 17th January, 2013. 
In all the matters where transfer has not yet been completed, 
those transfer petitions shall stand allowed and all the petitions, 
pending in the various courts, should be transferred to this Court 
by 15th January, 2013, and be treated as Transferred cases and be 
listed along with these Transferred cases and the writ petitions. 
In the meantime, the Medical Council of India, the Dental Council of 
India, as well as the States and Universities and other Institutions, 
will be entitled to conduct their respective examinations for the 
M.B.B.S, B.D.S. and PostGraduate courses, but shall not declare 
the results of the same, until further orders of this Court. 
Learned counsel for the respective parties are all directed to 
make available their written submissions by 7th January, 2013. 12
Let copies of this Order be made available to the advocates onrecord for the respective parties for communication to the 
concerned Authorities. 
Wide publicity may also be given to this Order by the States, 
Union of India, Medical Council of India and the Dental Council 
of India so that the students, who are intending to sit for the 
entrance examination, may have knowledge of the same. 

Case continued.Around 28 hearings occur..Many other days case was listed but not taken for hearing...90000 doctors who had written entrance waited for 5 months for results.In between many state and private medical colleges conducted their own exams.Many strikes occur in various states in India against private medical college and state exams.Now hearings are over and court instructed every petitioner that remain to argue to submit written submission.If NEET pg considered for admission in all medical colleges that will be a landmark judgement in medical pg admissions.we have to wait for one or two weeks to know the judgement in NEET case